Mattress Quiz

7 Best Crib Sheets to Make Sleep of Your Child Better

This article will help you choose hypoallergenic and soft sheets that will fit a variety of baby cribs.
By
Romeo Vitelli
Romeo Vitelli
Expert Writer
Received his doctorate in Psychology in 1987, spent fifteen years as a staff psychologist in Millbrook Correctional Centre. In 2003 went into full-time private practice. read more
reviewed
Reviewed By
Medical Advisory Team
Medical Advisory Team
Includes well-known professionals, who together provide decades of sleep medicine experience that enables Talk About Sleep to fulfill its mission of creating access to high- read more
Last updated: September 02, 2026
TalkAboutSleep is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

The wrong choice when it comes to crib sheets can make your child uncomfortable or even put them at risk in their own bed. Everyone wants their child to be protected and comfortable while they sleep. Did you know that the best crib sheets are one of the very best ways to keep your little one happy overnight?

In this guide, we’ve explored all of the key features of crib sheets and why they make such a big difference. Of course, we have ensured the crib sheet reviews are only for products that are safe and non-toxic. We’ve looked into the size, fit, thread count, material type, and color to ensure you can get something that can fit with your kids’ bedroom and keep them snug overnight.

Quick Summary

Top 7 Crib Sheets Review 2025

?
Consumer Engagement
9.9
Customer Feedback
Customer Feedback
9.4
Brand Reputation
Based onweb analytics
9.6
Features & Benefits
Product Review
9.8
9.9
Naturepedic Organic Crib Sheets
1
Editor’s Choice

Naturepedic Organic Crib Sheets See similar on Amazon

Naturepedic Organic Crib Sheets
Features
  • Material: 100% organic cotton (Sateen)
  • Size: 28 x 52 x 6 or 27 x 47 x 3 inches
  • Available colors: Ivory, White
  • Fit: fitted pockets

More features: smooth, one year warranty, machine washable, 300-thread count

This is a silky-smooth organic crib sheet that is perfect for your little one’s crib, even if they tend to move around a lot. It’s available in multiple sizes and is so incredibly smooth.

Because of the securely fitted pockets around the corners, this crib sheet set will stay in place even if you have a little squirmer for a child, and if they continue to move around, the sheets should stay in situ throughout the night. These are also great for kids who want something that feels soft, and the sateen design is pretty unique.

    Why is it special?
  • Of course, it's impossible not to like the fact that these sheets have a 300 thread count and offer loads of softness, but they're also so convenient. The way they easily fit around multiple designs of a crib and can stay securely in place means they are convenient. They can also be washed in a washing machine, and it doesn't lose any of the sateen softness in the process.
    What are the flaws?
  • If we're really fussy, it may be the case that you'd rather get something that has a more interesting design or a choice in design. It's only really available in a couple of lighter tones, whereas some of the other crib sheets have exciting designs. The sheet isn't the cheapest on the market, but it's far from being overly expensive.
?
Consumer Engagement
9.7
Customer Feedback
Customer Feedback
9.4
Brand Reputation
Based onweb analytics
9.4
Features & Benefits
Product Review
9.6
9.7
Newton Baby Organic Muslin Mini Crib Sheet 2-Pack
Newton Baby Organic Muslin Mini Crib Sheet 2-Pack
Features
  • Material: 100% organic cotton muslin
  • Size: fits mini crib mattresses 24 x 38 inches
  • Certification: GOTS certified
  • Fit: all-around elastic
  • Pack: 2 sheets

More features: pre-shrunk, machine washable, dryer safe, hypoallergenic

The Newton Baby Organic Muslin Mini Crib Sheet is a good match for parents who worry about heat building up around their baby. The 100% organic cotton muslin is very breathable and lets air move freely, so the bed stays comfortable on warm nights.

Elastic runs all the way around the sheet for a snug fit on a 24 x 38 inch mini crib mattress. The set comes with two sheets, so a clean one is ready when accidents happen, and both are pre-shrunk and safe for the washer and dryer.

    Why is it special?
  • Breathable organic cotton muslin
  • GOTS certified fabric
  • Snug all-around elastic fit
  • Two sheets in one pack
  • Pre-shrunk, machine washable and dryer safe
    What are the flaws?
  • Only fits mini crib mattresses, not standard cribs
  • Thin muslin feels lighter than jersey or flannel
  • Sold only as a 2-pack, not as a single sheet
?
Consumer Engagement
9.5
Customer Feedback
Customer Feedback
9.1
Brand Reputation
Based onweb analytics
9.4
Features & Benefits
Product Review
9.4
9.5
Moonsea 2-Pack Microfiber Fitted Crib Sheets
Moonsea 2-Pack Microfiber Fitted Crib Sheets
Features
  • Size: standard crib and toddler mattress, 52 x 28 x 8 inches
  • Material: 100% microfiber
  • Pack: 2 fitted sheets (grey and white)
  • Maintenance: machine washable on gentle cycle, tumble dry low or line dry

More features: elastic band around the entire edge, fade resistant, quick drying

If you want quality crib sheets without spending much, this Moonsea 2-pack is one of the cheapest ways to get them. The microfiber fabric is soft and breathable, and the elastic runs around the whole edge so the sheet stays snug on a standard crib or toddler mattress.

Because you get two sheets, there is always a clean one ready when the other is in the wash, and they are fade resistant and quick drying.

    What stands out?
  • Very affordable for a 2-pack
  • Soft, breathable microfiber
  • Elastic around the entire edge for a snug fit
  • Fade resistant and quick drying
    What cons did we manage to find?
  • Microfiber is not a natural fabric like cotton or muslin
  • Only the grey and white colors in this set
?
Consumer Engagement
9.4
Customer Feedback
Customer Feedback
8.9
Brand Reputation
Based onweb analytics
9.3
Features & Benefits
Product Review
9.3
9.4
BROLEX Stretchy Fitted Crib Sheets Set
BROLEX Stretchy Fitted Crib Sheets Set
Features
  • Material: jersey
  • Size: 58 x 28 x 9 inches
  • Available colors: Grey Teal, Elephant and Whale pattern
  • Fit: fitted with elastic bottom

More features: pack of two, machine washable, soft, fits portable mattress

The BROLEX Stretchy Fitted Crib Sheets Set is absolutely adorable. If you’re looking for a cute statement design for the crib or for a kid’s room, then this could be the ideal solution for you. However, you need a set of sheets that does everything you need it to and keeps your kid comfy, as well as being cute.

This set has an amazing way of clinging to the crib mattress, no matter what size of small mattress you are using. The fabric naturally grips around the edges, so it is great for those who want to quickly set up the crib.

    What do we love it for?
  • As well as being tight around the crib mattress, you can also enjoy the ease of use as this is totally machine washable. Just chuck it on your favorite cycle. The elasticated bottom has a lot of grip around the crib, so you can use this even with a kid who crawls around in the night. The soft jersey knit is also ideal for the skin, so you can avoid any rashes from harsh sheets.
    What were we disappointed with?
  • Though they're super soft and stretchy, on bigger crib mattresses, it can be difficult to get them to fit, as you have to stretch the edges around the corners of the crib, but this is what stops the sheet from bunching up, so it is worth getting right.
?
Consumer Engagement
9.3
Customer Feedback
Customer Feedback
8.8
Brand Reputation
Based onweb analytics
8.8
Features & Benefits
Product Review
9.2
9.3
mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted Crib Sheet
mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted Crib Sheet
Features
  • Material: cotton muslin
  • Size: 28 x 52 x 9 inches
  • Available colors: Fall Yellow, Blush, Fog, Natural, Natural Stripe, Rainbow, Roman Green, Tradewinds
  • Fit: fitted with elastic bottom

More features: extra soft, breathable, pre-washed, perfect fit

Although the thin Muslin may not be the best crib sheet for winter, the thin design is breathable and gives an amazing summer coolness for your little one. This mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted Crib Sheet comes in a variety of colors, and the sheet is extremely soft.

If you are looking for the best cotton crib sheets, these are great, as they are made out of 100% organic cotton. It makes a superb option for anyone who wants the tradition of Muslin.

    Why are we impressed?
  • The 22cm deep pockets are fantastic for giving a snug and secure fit, and you can make sure they sit neatly around the edges. We love the fact that it is easy to remove, and the design is simple, cozy, and soft. For a baby's skin in summer or winter, Muslin has been a preferred material for generations.
    What negatives must you be aware of?
  • Though it does have deep-fitting pockets, the mattress can be a little frustrating as it doesn't sit as tightly on the mattress as some others, so this means that a squirming child can result in bunched sheets. You need to also take extra care when washing, so it doesn't lose the soft feeling.
?
Consumer Engagement
9.2
Customer Feedback
Customer Feedback
9.1
Brand Reputation
Based onweb analytics
8.8
Features & Benefits
Product Review
8.7
9.2
American Baby Company Fitted Crib Sheet
6
Best Pack of 3 Crib Sheets

American Baby Company Fitted Crib Sheet

American Baby Company Fitted Crib Sheet
Features
  • Material: 100% cotton jersey knit
  • Size: 28 x 52 x 9 inches
  • Available colors: Pink Star/Zigzag, White, Pink, Grey Star/Zigzag, Grey, Blue Star/Zigzag, Blue
  • Fit: snug with deep pockets and elastic trim

More features: pack of three, soft, machine washable

The American Baby Company Fitted Crib Sheet is sold in packs of three, which makes them a really great value product, especially if you love the designs.

If you are looking for something that is 100% Cotton Jersey and fits a standard crib mattress, then this can be a great alternative to muslin sheets which can get more crumpled. The soft tee-shirt feel might be preferred by some little ones.

    Why is it special?
  • On top of the very reasonable price tag, this is a good option for those who have a standard 6" crib mattress and want a cotton model that can sit snugly. We love the fact that they come in packs of three, which all have some very cute designs, with deep pockets to fit nicely on your crib. These sheets are very well-made.
    What are the flaws?
  • There is a slightly misleading issue with the name, as you might assume these are made in the USA, but they are actually produced in Pakistan, but this is not a problem due to the fact that they are still very good quality. The design is from a US company.
?
Consumer Engagement
9.0
Customer Feedback
Customer Feedback
8.9
Brand Reputation
Based onweb analytics
8.8
Features & Benefits
Product Review
8.8
9.0
Burt's Bees Baby Organic Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet
Burt's Bees Baby Organic Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet
Features
  • Material: 100% organic cotton, GOTS certified
  • Fits: standard 28 x 52 x 5.5 inch crib and toddler mattresses
  • Care: machine washable
  • Warranty: not specified

More features: 360 degree elastic, extra fabric overlap on the bottom edge, 1-pack or 2-pack, watercolor prints and solid colors

This fitted crib sheet is made from 100% GOTS certified organic cotton that is built to handle repeated laundering without tearing, fading or losing its shape. The elastic runs all the way around, and extra fabric on the bottom edge helps keep the sheet from creeping up on a standard crib mattress.

The stretchy fabric slips over the corners easily, which helps a lot during late-night changes. It gets softer with each wash and comes in plenty of hand-painted watercolor prints and plain colors.

    What do we love it for?
  • Holds up well to frequent washing
  • Soft, breathable organic cotton
  • Snug fit with elastic all the way around
  • Gets softer after washing
  • Lots of prints and colors to choose from
    What were we disappointed with?
  • Only fits standard size crib and toddler mattresses
  • Not meant for mini or portable crib mattresses
  • Warranty is not specified

Things to Consider

This isn’t the sort of product to just impulse buy a design you like. There’s far more to consider than just how it looks, and it is easy to buy the wrong crib sheets if you aren’t sure what you are doing. Let’s dive into a buying guide to help you to choose the ideal crib sheets for your child. There’s actually quite a lot to understand when trying to find the right sheets, and below, we explore the right options for different seasons, as well as diving into the features such as the materials that make for a great set of sheets.
New parents have so many things to consider when they are buying products for their kids, but you’ll always want to make sure you’ve got something that is safe and secure for your little one’s crib. There are some vital considerations below.

How to Choose the Best Crib Sheets?

How to Choose the Best Crib Sheets

So, how can you choose the best crib sheets? Whether you are looking for the best cotton-fitted crib sheets or you want a more unusual material, such as the cheaper microfiber models on the list, there are certain things to consider when choosing the best sheet.

Think about:

  • Whether you are living in a hotter or cooler location may help you to choose whether you need a thin and lightweight model or something a little thicker. Thread count Trusted Source What does thread count really mean? | HowStuffWorks Thread count means the number of threads woven together in a square inch. Find out what that really means and if we’re being tricked by thread count. home.howstuffworks.com can help you to make this decision.
  • While this isn’t the number one consideration, it is still great to find something that has a cute design that fits with decor. Lots of parents have a great time decorating their child’s room.
  • Size and fit. Luckily, the sizes of crib sheets and mattresses have been standardized, though there are some cribs out there that are a little more awkward in terms of how they look and feel. This means that you need to spend a bit of time considering or even measuring the mattress to make sure your sheet is going to fit perfectly.
  • As you will need to change your crib sheets regularly, a multipack can be a great way to make sure you always have enough and don’t run out; you should have a few sheets on rotation at all times.
  • Keep reading to understand all the vital features of crib sheet reviews and how you can choose the best.

Important Features

Time to explore those important features. Before you buy a set of crib sheets for the first time, you might not fully understand the features and how to understand them.

Material

A lot of people go for cotton-based materials such as Muslin Trusted Source Fabric 101: What Is Muslin? How to Use and Care for Muslin Lightweight and breathable, muslin is a loose plain weave cotton material that dates back to Ancient India. Today, muslin’s value is in its versatility and it is used in everything from photography backdrops to cooking to surgical procedures. www.masterclass.com , which has been used for generations for baby products.

Some materials such as microfiber have become popular in recent years, and microfiber sheets such as the Moonsea 2-Pack Microfiber Fitted Crib Sheets are one of the cheapest ways to get quality sheets. You may think of microfiber as the sort of material used for cleaning products, but it has many uses as a smart fabric that can even be used to make crib sheets.

100% cotton sheets are still really popular, especially as the breathable design keeps a kid cool during the summer months and warm on the cooler nights of winter, too. Jersey cotton tends to be thicker but still may be breathable enough so that you can use it all year round.

Size

Standard cribs measure 28″ x 52” while mini cribs are 24″ x 38”. This means that you need to find crib sheets that can fit nicely. A lot of the sheets have a depth of 8 or 9 inches to fit the mattress, and many have deep pockets. This means that you can fit the sheets around the corners and keep them snug and secure. Mini crib sheets can be slightly smaller and still do the same job. Mini cribs are great for uses such as travel.

Size

Colors

There’s no point in thinking too much about colors from a functional point of view. Instead, you should just think about the design that you like! Lighter colors might be better to prevent heat absorption, but they won’t make a huge difference. The key is finding something that fits the decor of your nursery or kid’s room.

A lot of the cool crib sheets on our list have amazing designs, including cute little elephants! There are also some really cute patterns. Check out the Burt’s Bees Baby Organic Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet if you want to see just how many cute patterns there are available on the market.

Fit

What sort of fit are you looking for? A lot of parents opt for a snug fit. The best-fitted crib sheets can avoid the child being able to move them around when they are sleeping. Some kids naturally crawl around and move a lot in their sleep, which can lead to the sheets becoming loose. You definitely don’t want to opt for sheets that don’t have a snug and secure fit as these can be a risk to children, who can get them wrapped around their face and struggle to breathe.

Elasticated areas at the bottom of the sheet are often the best way to make sure you have a sheet that is going to fit and sit around the bottom of the mattress.

Maintenance

Of course, you need to keep your sheets clean and in great condition. The BROLEX Stretchy Fitted Crib Sheets Set is machine washable. This means that it is really easy to keep them in the best possible condition. This is the only real maintenance you need to be aware of. Some people opt to hand wash and even add softening products to keep the fabric feels as smooth as possible.

FAQ

Which sheets are the safest ones for babies?

You can’t think enough about your child’s safety. When you are buying a crib sheet, it is important to consider your baby and what will keep them safest. Regulating temperature is a big deal; you don’t want your child to get too hot or too cold in their crib, and the sheets you use can play a big part in this. Being breathable is another big benefit, as you can rest assured that even if your kid manages to get tangled up in the sheets, they will be able to breathe comfortably through the night.

Do crib sheets need any special maintenance?

While most crib sheets are really easy to maintain, as you can just put them in the washing machine, some people choose to either hand wash or even add some fabric softener in order to keep them incredibly light and smooth to the touch. If not, over time, they can become rough, and your kid’s skin could even get irritated. While special maintenance isn’t required, special care and attention are a good idea when you consider the fact that your child is going to be using these products for sleeping.

How often should one change sheets in a crib?

It sounds like a lot, but at least every three days. Dust, hair, and dead skin cells gather on any bed and especially in a baby’s crib. Your child is growing so quickly. It’s important that you think about this when it comes to changing the sheets. This is why so many people go for a multipack so that they can always have a clean change of sheets. We recommend changing at least once every three nights. This can seem like a lot of work, so it is easy to see why so many people go for machine washable crib sheets rather than models needing more maintenance.

Our verdict

Crib sheets are a vital product, and while you can buy some options on a budget, it is worth spending some time researching to get the fit right along with a crib sheet to keep your child comfy and secure overnight.

Top of our list with a rating of 9.9 is the Naturepedic Organic Crib Sheets, the best organic crib sheets that offer a lot of comforts, and they are great for a variety of shapes and sizes of cribs, too.

Next is the Newton Baby Organic Muslin Mini Crib Sheet 2-Pack, with a rating of 9.7/10. We love the muslin design, which is incredibly light and breathable, which shows why families have considered Muslin the best crib sheets for hundreds of years. This is still a very popular material.

The value pick is the Moonsea 2-Pack Microfiber Fitted Crib Sheets with its affordable microfiber design. This is still soft and snug, and we’ve given it 9.5/10 as a rating. It’s incredibly good for the money.

References

1.
What does thread count really mean? | HowStuffWorks
Thread count means the number of threads woven together in a square inch. Find out what that really means and if we’re being tricked by thread count.
2.
Fabric 101: What Is Muslin? How to Use and Care for Muslin
Lightweight and breathable, muslin is a loose plain weave cotton material that dates back to Ancient India. Today, muslin’s value is in its versatility and it is used in everything from photography backdrops to cooking to surgical procedures.
9,9
Total Score
Naturepedic Organic Crib Sheets - Editor’s Choice
Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

X